…now i’m just annoyed with Maine… this is disgusting that we can’t keep same sex marriage laws on the books.
Please note, in this blog post, i use “we” royally – referring to Americans, in general. No particular party, religious affiliation, etc
We, straight people can’t even get marriage right – a t least in the American sense of the word… Why should we be the ones dictating the right to same-sex couples? We are unique and Western in our views and notions of boy meets girl (or boy), falls in love, and come-what-may/happy-ever-after – you’ve got a partner for life, someone whose foot isn’t out the door if everything goes wrong (something that is extremely important to me… i have abandonment issues, i suppose)
What goes wrong then with us Americans? I mean, we already have a 50% failure rate (or 50% success rate depending on how you want to look at it!) The infatuation part fades (especially after the first 18 months – 2 years, all those “in love” pheromones fade) – and what’s left after that determines everything. I’m definitely a proponent of living it up at the first section – because you’ll never get that time back, but I digress. So… we have a system that we get to choose our partners. And when things do go tragically wrong (and I don’t think divorce is something that is chosen lightly – but i feel the same way about marriage), we have a system of no-fault divorce and we use it.
When no-fault divorce was being enacted, we heard a lot of the same arguments about protecting the institution of marriage. How no-fault divorce would only weaken the institution and marriage would be taken lightly. Vegas does still exist, as does Gaitlinburg and any other town that thrives on the shotgun wedding institution. On the other hand, we are becoming more cautious about marriage. The number of children born out of wedlock is dramatically on the rise. We marry out of necessity less and less. We are more likely to cohabitat, fornicate and so forth instead of getting married immediately. We demand faithfulness and monogamy. This is our Western privilege. Much of the world still views marriage as a pre-ordained, business transaction.
We don’t get married out of biological necessity anymore. We may over financial necessity and betterment – but we have more options than we used to. We get married because we choose to. We love each other and commit to each other and we really do try. Without the same kinds of obligatory bindings holding us together, things change. I really do want to do it right when I finally get there – but for now, I know I don’t have to fall within previous generations of martial pressures. And what will drive me to marriage, drives same sex couples to marriage: love, determination, partnership – not a family, finances, and gender expectations.
So what right do we have to determine who gets married? We had this debate with interracial marriage. And how was it solved? Through legislation and finally, a Supreme Court decision (Loving v. Virginia) Even recently, we have heard from one individual who attempted to deny a couple the right to an interracial marriage. I’m sure there are people in the South who still think that Justice of the Peace was right. (I say this with absolute disgust that he even thought he had the right to deny a marriage!) By the time the Supreme Court had overturned any anti-miscegenation laws, 16 states still had these laws in place. I’m sure a popular vote would not have come very easily in 1967.
At this rate, I’m sick of seeing gay marriage on the ballot. I’m sick of it not succeeding. Its time for bigger, more permanent action take place. Let’s start with repealing DOMA and damn it, I want to see the Supreme Court overturn all laws that will not allow same sex couples to enjoy the same benefits as heterosexual marriages. After all, they are doing it for the same reasons.
P.S. Congrats to Washington for approving Ref. 71 – protecting the civil unions for same sex couples.